Sightings of the Midvale creature have surfaced sporadically over the decades, each adding to its unsettling legend. Hunters reported glimpsing it at dawn near Crane Creek, its reflection rippling across the water before vanishing into the brush. Teenagers claimed to hear its chilling cry at night, a sound caught between a bray and a human scream. Ranchers found tracks too wide for a hoof and too large for a man pressed deep into the mud after storms. While skeptics dismiss these accounts as exaggerations or tricks of the light, others insist the creature is real—an elusive presence that slips between farmland and wilderness, revealing itself only to the unlucky or the chosen few.

• 1982 – Midvale, Idaho: Rancher C.K. Taylor reports seeing the creature at dusk while checking irrigation lines; describes donkey-like ears, a horse-like head, cow body, and massive humanlike footprint.

• Mid-1980s – Crane Creek: A hunter claims to spot the beast drinking at dawn, its reflection visible in the water before it vanishes into the brush.

• Late 1980s – Outskirts of Midvale: Teenagers camping near the river swear they hear a chilling cry—half bray, half human scream—echoing through the night.

• 1990s – After a summer storm: Oversized, flat tracks are discovered in muddy fields, too wide for a hoof and too large for a man.

• 2000s – Rural backroads: Motorists report glimpses of a large, loping figure crossing fields at twilight, moving with a gait unlike any known animal.

• 2010s – Seasonal hay harvest: Ranch hands whisper of strange shapes watching from the tree line, ears flicking in the fading light.

• Present Day: Stories continue to circulate, with believers insisting the creature still roams the valley, slipping between farmland and wilderness unseen.